Eureka Health vs One Medical – Which App Handles Labs and Prescriptions With Less Hassle?
😩 Tired of endless health Googling?
You deserve answers that actually make sense. Eureka is an AI doctor that listens, remembers, and never dismisses your concerns. Built for people who refuse to settle for "just get more sleep" as medical advice.
Key Takeaways
If your biggest headache is booking a lab test or renewing a prescription, Eureka Health currently feels lighter and faster than One Medical. Eureka’s AI can suggest evidence-based tests, generate a lab order, and push it to partnered diagnostic networks – all inside a free iOS app. Prescriptions work the same way: the AI writes a draft, a licensed clinician signs off, and the medication appears at your chosen pharmacy, often in a few hours. One Medical still requires a video or in-office visit with a clinician before any order is placed, and membership costs about $199 per year. For people who like instant, 24/7 self-service, Eureka trims several steps. For patients who prefer face-to-face primary care and physical offices in major U.S. cities, One Medical delivers that familiarity. Which one is “better” depends on how hands-on you want a human to be, but for pure convenience around labs and scripts, Eureka is ahead today.
You’re weighing two very different health tools: Eureka Health, a free AI doctor that lives on your phone, and One Medical, a membership-based primary-care group backed by Amazon. Your main goal isn’t small talk with a provider — you just need lab work ordered quickly and prescriptions filled without phone-tag. In this comparison we’ll lay out exactly how each app handles those tasks, where each one shines, and where you might hit friction. No fluff, just the facts you need to pick an app that matches your lifestyle.
How do both apps actually place a lab order?
Eureka lets you request a test inside any chat. When the AI decides a lab is appropriate, it creates an electronic order; a licensed physician on Eureka’s team reviews and releases it to a national lab partner. You get a barcode on your phone to take to the draw site. One Medical follows the traditional flow: you schedule a virtual or in-person visit, discuss the need, and the clinician orders the test through One Medical’s EHR, typically directing you to Quest or Labcorp. That means your speed depends on appointment availability.
- Eureka: order in minutes, 24/7No appointment slots. Chat, agree on the test, receive the digital requisition instantly after clinician sign-off.
- One Medical: order after a visitRequires video or office visit first. Same-day slots exist in some markets, but many users wait a day or more.
- Result deliveryBoth apps surface PDF results in-app, but Eureka auto-explains each value and updates your Health Vault.
| Step | Eureka Health | One Medical |
|---|---|---|
| Request | Type in chat | Book visit |
| Clinician sign-off | Asynchronous within app | Live visit |
| Go to lab | Barcode in wallet | Lab slip or electronic order |
| Result interpretation | AI summary instantly | Message clinician for context |
“Eureka ordered my thyroid panel at 2 a.m. The requisition was in my inbox before I finished brushing my teeth.” – Jamie, 29
Become your owndoctor 🩺
Eureka is an expert medical AI built for
What about prescription refills and new meds?
Both platforms can legally prescribe in states where they operate, but the workflow feels different. Eureka’s AI drafts the prescription from the chat context and routes it to a supervising physician. Once approved, the e-script heads to the pharmacy you choose in your profile. One Medical requires a visit; during that conversation the provider sends the prescription. Refills can be requested in-app but still need provider review, usually within one business day.
- SpeedEureka often completes a straightforward refill in under an hour. One Medical quotes up to one business day.
- After-hours accessEureka’s AI operates 24/7 with clinician backup on call. One Medical’s after-hours team can advise but may not transmit new prescriptions until the next morning.
- Chronic medication trackingEureka logs adherence and side-effects automatically from chat check-ins. One Medical relies on scheduled follow-ups.
How much will you pay?
Eureka is free while in public beta; you only pay the lab’s fee or pharmacy copay. One Medical charges a $199 yearly membership (or $9.99 monthly in some regions) on top of regular service costs. Insurance can offset lab and medication fees on both platforms.
- App access costEureka: $0 today. One Medical: membership required.
- Visit feesEureka: none for AI chat. One Medical: insurance co-pay for visits, or cash rate if uninsured.
- Hidden costsNeither charges for secure messaging, but One Medical bills some extended messaging as a visit under certain plans.
Does AI change the quality of care?
Eureka’s model pulls from your entire Health Vault history, learns patterns, and cites peer-reviewed sources for every recommendation. If your ferritin trends low across several tests, it flags that automatically and suggests follow-up labs or dosing changes. One Medical offers human clinical judgment, but each appointment starts with limited chart recall and depends on the clinician’s memory.
- Memory advantageEureka remembers every symptom and result you log; One Medical providers may skim notes from prior visits.
- Evidence linksEureka cites guidelines in-line. One Medical relies on the provider to explain verbally or send links later.
- EscalationEureka forwards edge-cases to its medical team; One Medical books you with a specialist inside its network or externally.
“The AI connected my low B-12 from last year to my current fatigue and ordered a repeat level. My PCP never mentioned it.” – Carlos, 41
Which app fits different lifestyles?
If you travel, work night shifts, or just hate scheduling visits, Eureka’s asynchronous chat and instant orders feel liberating. If you value a brick-and-mortar clinic for vaccines or physical exams, One Medical’s 125+ offices make more sense.
- Best for self-directed usersEureka excels when you want to drive your own testing and medication management.
- Best for hands-on careOne Medical suits people wanting an annual physical, on-site labs, and same-day in-person appointments.
The bottom line: which one should you choose for labs and scripts?
Choose Eureka if you need speed, 24/7 access, and AI-driven follow-through without extra membership fees. Choose One Medical if you prefer a traditional clinician relationship and are willing to schedule visits for every new order. Many users keep both: Eureka for quick logistics, One Medical for physical exams.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Eureka Health actually prescribe medications legally?
Yes. A licensed physician reviews every AI-generated prescription before it is transmitted to your pharmacy, meeting state and federal regulations.
Do I still need a human doctor if I use Eureka?
Eureka covers many routine needs, but the app recommends seeing an in-person clinician for exams, imaging, or urgent issues that require physical evaluation.
What happens if Eureka’s AI can’t help with my condition?
The chat escalates to a human clinician for review. If the case is beyond telehealth scope, you receive a referral to an appropriate provider.
Which app is faster for getting lab results?
Eureka usually edges out One Medical because you skip scheduling; however, both depend on the lab’s processing time once the sample is collected.
Can I link my existing health records to these apps?
Eureka offers a one-click import from most U.S. health systems. One Medical syncs only visits done within its network, though you can upload PDFs manually.
Is One Medical available outside the United States?
No. One Medical operates only in selected U.S. metro areas. Eureka is available worldwide on iOS.
Which platform is better for chronic conditions?
Eureka’s continuous chat and memory help with ongoing tweaks to meds or labs. One Medical provides regular in-person touchpoints, which some chronic patients prefer.
How quickly are prescription refills processed?
Eureka often approves simple refills within an hour. One Medical states up to one business day, though urgent requests can be expedited.
Can I cancel One Medical membership any time?
Monthly subscribers can cancel in the app before the next billing cycle. Annual memberships are non-refundable after 30 days.
What can I ask Eureka Health?
Anything from interpreting your lipid panel to building a migraine plan. If it’s outside telehealth scope, the AI will tell you.